Following two straight wins, the performance was a step back for Brendan McCartney's developing team, who went goalless in the opening term and had only two to half-time as Collingwood opened a 53-point buffer.
By contrast, the Magpies looked dangerous every time they went into attack, with Cloke dominant in the air and their battery of small forwards swooping when the ball hit the ground.
With 34 goals for the season, Cloke now sits equal second in the Coleman Medal, one behind leader Lindsay Thomas.
Midfielders Dane Swan and Scott Pendlebury ran rampant for Collingwood, controlling the stoppages – usually the Bulldogs' strength – and collecting a combined 73 disposals.
"We've only really put four quarters together maybe three or four times," Buckley said.
However he took a philosophical approach post-game, happy to be 8-4 going into the bye and understanding that any team with eight players who have played fewer than 25 games will be inconsistent.
Collingwood also had the game won at half-time, restricting the Bulldogs to two goals and having a 53-point lead.
"We defended really well, didn't give them any outlets, forced them sideways and slow and that was off the back of our structure and [guarding] dangerous space," Buckley said.
He was disappointed with their approach early. "We were a bit safe ... I'm not sure if they defended brilliantly, they defended quite well but we didn't test them enough either," McCartney said.
He said the inexperience of some players caused them at times to second-guess themselves.
However he was happy with the efforts of the second half and the team's ability to adjust given the scoreline at half-time.
Collingwood heads into the bye with a win-loss record of 8-4 while the Bulldogs are 3-8 and sit 14th, narrowly ahead of the Brisbane Lions on percentage.
They'll return to Etihad Stadium next week to face Richmond, while the Magpies will enjoy a weekend off before travelling west to take on Port Adelaide in a fortnight.
Magpies star Dane Swan tackles Bulldogs veteran Robert Murphy. Picture AFL Media
ROUND TABLE: Who can stop the Swans, Pies pair making waves
Join Josh Gabelich, Sarah Olle, Nat Edwards and Damian Barrett for AFL Round Table ahead of another huge round of footy
05:18
Footy Feed: Fresh De Goey injury, Libba latest, Lion's big plans
Nat Edwards with all the latest news
43:44
Talkin' It Up: Lydia Williams' incredible life as a Matilda, Olympian, author, advocate
Lydia Williams on growing up in the desert with a Noongar father and American mother, her experience of identity and Indigenous culture, finding football and accolades at the highest level, why she has always advocated for women in sport, and what’s next post-retirement
00:51
YOKAYI FOOTY SHORTS: Should all teams adopt traditional owners names for SDNR?
Andy Krakouer weighs in on whether the remaining 12 clubs should change names for Sir Doug Nicholls Round