Main content

Recommended videos

Highlights: Richmond v Carlton

11:17pm Mar 27, 2014

Malthouse rues costly mistakes

11:44pm Mar 27, 2014

Recommended articles

Sunday football as it happened

Sunday football as it happened

Recap Port's Showdown upset, plus big wins for the Hawks and Tigers

11:45am Apr 14, 2013

St Kilda v Richmond as it happened

St Kilda v Richmond as it happened

 Recap Friday night's MCG clash as the Tigers make their best start to a season in 16 years

04:00pm Apr 5, 2013

Carlton v Collingwood as it happened

Carlton v Collingwood as it happened

Recap Friday night's blockbuster as the Blues capitulate in front of 78,000 at the MCG

10:36pm Jul 5, 2013

Saturday football as it happened

Saturday football as it happened

Recap a day bookended by two major boilovers

01:00pm Mar 30, 2013

Fantasy review: round three

Fantasy review: round three

It was a tough round for AFL Fantasy coaches, Warnie writes

10:42pm Apr 6, 2014

Football world sends off Hafey in style

Football world sends off Hafey in style

Tom Hafey remembered as a great coach and a wonderful man

06:15pm May 19, 2014

Fantasy Face-off: Shaw v Broughton

Michael Whiting  February 21, 2013 7:00 AM

Fantasy Face-Off: Heath Shaw v Greg Broughton Will you ride the Magpie rollercoaster in 2013, or take a punt on the reborn Sun?


They've both been solid AFL Fantasy citizens for a number of year but who's best placed to deliver you maximum return on investment in 2013 - Heath Shaw or Greg Broughton?
 
  HEATH SHAW
 
GREG BROUGHTON
 
Fantasy position
 
Defender Defender/Forward
2013 price $422,800 $408,000
2012 average 82.06 79.2
2012 high score 115 109
Age 27 26
X-factor, Rising Star or Mr Reliable? Mr Reliable. With a top score last season of 115 and an average of 82, Shaw doesn't fluctuate too much. He knows his role, when to run off and when to stay at home, and is bankable in most games.
 
X-factor. Fell foul of Ross Lyon last year where he was moved all over the ground. As a new Sun, expect a few games of adjustment but he's shown in years past he can deliver big numbers on occasion.
 
Value for money Shaw is right around where he should be. A consistent player for many seasons now, he spent some time on the wing last year but should revert back to his defensive home in 2013. Represents decent value. Last season he was moved into unfamiliar roles but with a set position in the back half in 2013, the former Docker has some scope to rise in price. Dual position option increases that value.
 
Job security One of the most influential players in Collingwood's team, when fit, Shaw is one of the first chosen. He gives the backline run and when available is a certain selection. Gold Coast didn't recruit him to sit on the pine. Barring injury, Broughton is a certainty for round one and will play as many of the 22 games as his body allows. Will be one of the first picked.
 
Injury history Shaw missed some time with a calf injury last year, but still played 18 games and in general he stays away from the physio's table. Had a great pre-season and at 27, is still in his athletic prime.
 
Suffered a broken finger in round 15 last year that curtailed his season, but Broughton is well and truly over that and has trained strongly the entire pre-season.
The case for Shaw has been a lynchpin in a successful Collingwood team for years. The Magpies again look like being right in the mix in 2013, and you'd expect Shaw to be at his dashing best from half-back. Time on the wing won't do AFL Fantasy scores any harm. He's has averaged more than 19 disposals a game for each of the past seven seasons. Since entering the AFL in 2009 as a mature-age player, Broughton has shown himself to be both prolific and consistent. He may have changed teams, but he's returning to his favoured backline position where he has a chance to flourish. A great get for the Suns and AFL Fantasy coaches.
The case against When the Magpies put in the odd stinker, his scores plummet too. Off-field indiscretions are hopefully a think of the past.
 
Will he fit in with a new team? While Broughton returns to the backline, he may be forced to think 'defence first' in a back six that will again be under siege.

The verdict
There's no loser in this face-off. Broughton looks a perfect fit for the Suns, but is untested in his new surroundings. Playing in a better team and having done it for a longer period, I'd lean towards Shaw.
 

Play NAB AFL Fantasy now.