Main content

Blues do enough to fend off fiery Saints

Highlights: St Kilda v Carlton The Saints and Blues clash in round 8
Dale Thomas of the Blues celebrates a goal during the 2014 AFL Round 08 match between the St Kilda Saints and the Carlton Blues at Etihad Stadium, Melbourne on May 12, 2014. (Photo: Justine Walker/AFL Media)
Dale Thomas was quiet but kicked one goal against the Saints
BRYCE Gibbs has led Carlton to its third win of the season, a gritty 32-point win over St Kilda at Etihad Stadium on Monday night.
 
The midfielder, who has been the subject of much speculation over his future with the club, was central to the Blues' 15.11 (101) to 9.15 (69) win.
 
The 25-year-old gathered 38 disposals – the second most prolific outing of his 163-game career – to sink the Saints, whose midfield brigade was outclassed and outworked by Carlton's line-up.

 
Carlton may have a concern, however, with Marc Murphy likely to come under scrutiny by the Match Review Panel for a clash with opposing Saints skipper Nick Riewoldt in the third quarter.
 
While Murphy appeared to attempt to avoid bumping Riewoldt, the champion Saint was collected and left the field for almost 10 minutes while being tested for concussion before returning.
 
The Blues did most of their damage in a blistering second term, piling on eight straight goals and opening up a 39-point lead at the main break.

"We went out there to defend the ball and the best form of defence is to have the ball and from that we were able to score. There was no freewheeling, let's blister the scoreboard, let me tell you that right now," Blues coach Mick Malthouse said following the win.

 
"That consistency we just haven't really been able to mount that practically all year. It's something we as coaches look at just to (try to) find a common denominator." 
 
After a sloppy and scrappy first term, which wouldn't have impressed the lowly crowd of 26,708, the Blues were kickstarted by youngster Troy Menzel, who booted three goals for the term.
 
First was a checkside from the pocket, then a snap after a sidestep and then a 50m bomb from a set shot, displaying just a pinch of the 19-year-old's immeasurable talents.
 
Chris Yarran was another to shine, kicking two of his three goals in the term, one of which one came after a four-bounce run through the centre corridor.
 
Gibbs was clearly best afield. His possessions had value, he set up opportunities, and seemed to have time and space for most of the game.

 
Kade Simpson (36 touches), Brock McLean (29) and Marc Murphy (32) were solid, and Dylan Buckley continued his breakout season with tenacity and run from defence.
 
Where the Blues had a bevy of goalkicking options in the game-breaking second quarter, the Saints looked almost solely to captain Nick Riewoldt.
 
No.3 draft pick Jack Billings chipped in with a classy conversion but there was little else in support for Riewoldt.
 
Something changed after half-time.
 
All of a sudden, the Saints had options. Adam Schneider kicked a goal, and Luke Dunstan ripped the ball out and snapped one of his own.
 
With Riewoldt off the ground for almost 10 minutes while recovering from his knock, St Kilda's movement became more unpredictable, and others became more involved.

The Saints cut the margin to 27 points by the last change, but could have been more, having booted 2.7. They left themselves with too much to do.
 
"[It was] nine scoring shots to two, and potentially could have made a game of it. There was some belief among the group, you could sense that at three-quarter time," Saints coach Alan Richardson said post-game.

"There's no doubt that if you're not going all that well, and you're up against some real quality … we just couldn't quite match it there. If we had of made the most of those opportunities, who knows?"
 
Riewoldt finished with four goals – taking his season tally to 22 – and tried hard all night, fellow veterans Lenny Hayes (30 disposals) and Adam Schneider (26) provided some experience, and Billings continued to show why he was such an early draft choice with 15 touches and two goals.

Jack Newnes and Mitch Robinson grapple during Monday night's clash. Picture: AFL Media



ST KILDA          1.1     4.3     6.10     9.15   (69)
CARLTON          2.6   10.6    11.7    15.11  (101)
 
GOALS
St Kilda:  Riewoldt 4, Billings 2, Acres, Schneider, Dunstan,
Carlton: Yarran 4, Menzel 3, Docherty 2, Simpson, Thomas, Ellard, Jamison, Robinson, Garlett
 
BEST 
St Kilda: Hayes, Riewoldt, Schneider, Montagna, Billings
Carlton: Gibbs, Yarran, Simpson, Menzel, Murphy, McLean, Warnock
 
INJURIES 
St Kilda: Nil
Carlton: Nil
 
SUBSTITUTES
St Kilda: Blake Acres replaced by Maverick Weller in the third quarter
Carlton: David Ellard replaced by Jeff Garlett in the fourth quarter
 
Reports: Nil
 
Umpires: Donlon, Bannister, Chamberlain
 
Official crowd: 26,708 at Etihad Stadium