Main content

Match report: Giants edge Pies for first win

AFLW Highlights: Collingwood v GWS The Magpies and the Giants clash in round 3 of the AFLW

GREATER Western Sydney has won its first game for the NAB AFL Women's season, overcoming Collingwood by 13 points.

The Giants' 7.6 (48) to 5.5 (35) victory leaves Collingwood winless after three matches and almost certainly out of the race for a Grand Final berth. 

The match came to life in the second half, with momentum continually swinging between the two sides.

But in the end, the weight of inside 50s (37-18) proved to be too much for the Magpies defence missing an injured Stacey Livingstone, who will undergo surgery on her shoulder this week.

The Magpies, boosted by the additions of Moana Hope and Meg Hutchins – the veteran defender picked for her first game this season and playing up forward – had started full of purpose, kicking the opening two goals.

But a Cora Staunton-inspired Giants owned the second quarter, albeit inaccurately, kicking 1.5. Staunton kicked three behinds, while teammate Aimee Schmidt was sharper, with two goals in two minutes. 

Staunton was also forced from the field just before half-time after copping an elbow to the face while tackling Magpie Sophie Casey.

 

Coach Alan McConnell said she would require an x-ray on her "bent" nose, and may not fly back with the team on Sunday night.

Midfielder Courtney Gum kicked two goals in the last quarter to wrest the game away from a dogged Collingwood, who had been given late hope through a Hope goal. 

Successive goals to Giants key forwards Jacinda Barclay and Phoebe McWilliams put the game beyond doubt.

It was a "devastated" Collingwood coach Wayne Siekman who spoke post-match, making the point the much-discussed guidelines set down by the AFL was making life difficult for his players.

"It is what it is," Siekman said.

"It's hard because you go to a game like last night's (Carlton v Brisbane) and you're trying to see the changes and what you can implement and what you think you can do. You see things start a different way, then the umpires adjudicate it differently, then the next day it's back to a different way, it's hard to get consistency.

"Our players are trying to learn the game, because they haven't been in a TAC Cup program, they haven't been playing elite football for five years, they're all still learning. It's so hard to keep adjusting and these poor females are having to keep adjusting. Imagine what their brains are going through."

Adding salt to the wound, former Pie Alicia Eva was one of the Giants' best, with a game-high 23 touches forcing Siekman to put Britt Bonnici on her as a tag in the fourth quarter. But it was to no avail, as Bonnici's former opponent Gum bobbed up to kick those two important goals.

 

Point of difference
GWS' win came on the back of sheer weight of inside 50s. The Giants' second quarter return of 1.5 could have won the game there and then if they had kicked accurately. But if you keep kicking at goal, the tide has to turn at some point, and it did in the last quarter. The Giants followed their scoreless third term with five goals straight in the fourth and finished with an inside-50 count of 37-18.

Remember me?
While Tayla Harris may have struggled against her former club on Saturday night, Alicia Eva was one of the Giants' best against her old Collingwood teammates. After requesting a trade up north, Eva has fitted in seamlessly, adding some much-needed nous to the Giants' line-up. The tireless onballer ran riot, recording a match-high 23 disposals, three marks and three tackles. Her pace and creativity was something the Magpies desperately missed at points during the match. 

Where there's life, there's Hope
All eyes were on reinstated Collingwood forward Moana Hope, returning for her first game after her omission last week. It was a mixed day for last season's marquee signing, who marked strongly but struggled with her field kicking. She kicked a stunning dribble goal from the pocket in the third term, as well as a gimmie from a 50-metre penalty in the goal square and has probably done enough to hold her place. 

 

A win for the ages
GWS coach Alan McConnell has been around top-level footy circles for decades, but the win against Collingwood was his first as senior coach. McConnell was the interim coach at the tail end of each of Fitzroy's final two seasons in 1995 and 1996 but did not record a win. He came to the post-match media conference covered in (hopefully orange) Gatorade from an exuberant playing group and said during his Fitzroy days there was "zero chance" he thought his first senior win would come from coaching a team of women. 

Say what?
"I'm delighted for the girls. We're a bit like Dad's Army, our team, we come from everywhere and we've got a whole lot of girls who were told they're no good and a lot of girls who have come out of New South Wales battling the notion that football isn't the same there as the rest of the country. To get some reward for effort is just fabulous, absolutely fabulous." – GWS coach Alan McConnell

"We had a good chat after the game with the players. There was some really good patches from us, certainly the first quarter I felt we were pretty dominant … but that second quarter they were coming hard, their inside-50 numbers were off the charts" – Collingwood coach Wayne Siekman 

Up Next
Collingwood travels to Alice Springs for a daunting match-up against Melbourne, while GWS takes on a rejuvenated Adelaide at Blacktown.

 

COLLINGWOOD                             2.3   2.4   4.5   5.5 (35)                  
GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY      0.1   2.6   2.6   7.6 (48)          

GOALS
Collingwood: Hope 2, Bonnici, Chiocci, Duffin
GWS: Schmidt 2, Gum 2, McWilliams 2, Barclay

BEST 
Collingwood: Bonnici, King, Molloy, Duffin, Hope
GWS: Eva, Gum, McWilliams, Farrugia, Staunton 

INJURIES 
Collingwood: Nil
GWS: Staunton (nose)

Reports: Nil 

Umpires: Rawlings, Adair, Burns

Crowd: 3,600 at Olympic Park Oval