Presented to the player judged, by an independent panel of football experts, to be best on ground in the Grand Final.
Norm Smith was a famous Melbourne Football Club identity who was also associated with Fitzroy and South Melbourne at senior level. Smith played a total of 227 games with Melbourne and Fitzroy and coached in a total of 452 games with Melbourne (310), Fitzroy (55) and South Melbourne (87).
During his 310-game tenure coaching Melbourne, he took the club into every Grand Final between 1954 and 1960 and won six premierships in the years 1955, 1956, 1957, 1959, 1960, 1964. He played from 1935 to 1950, and coached at senior level every year between 1949 and 1972, except 1968. Smith died in 1973, aged 57.

YEAR   PLAYER (Club)
1979   Wayne Harmes (Carlton)
1980   Kevin Bartlett (Richmond)
1981   Bruce Doull (Carlton)
1982   Maurice Rioli (Richmond)
1983   Colin Robertson (Hawthorn)
1984   Billy Duckworth (Essendon)
1985   Simon Madden (Essendon)
1986   Gary Ayres (Hawthorn)
1987   David Rhys-Jones (Carlton)
1988   Gary Ayres (Hawthorn)
1989   Gary Ablett (Geelong)
1990   Tony Shaw (Collingwood)
1991   Paul Dear (Hawthorn)
1992   Peter Matera (West Coast Eagles)
1993   Michael Long (Essendon)
1994   Dean Kemp (West Coast Eagles)
1995   Greg Williams (Carlton)
1996   Glenn Archer (kangaroos)
1997   Andrew McLeod (Adelaide)
1998   Andrew McLeod (Adelaide)
1999   Shannon Grant (Kangaroos)
2000   James Hird (Essendon)
2001   Shaun Hart (Brisbane)
2002   Nathan Buckley (Collingwood)
2003   Simon Black (Brisbane)
2004   Byron Pickett (Port Adelaide)
2005   Chris Judd(West Coast Eagles)