IS NEW Lion Lachie Neale an adequate replacement for departed former skipper Dayne Beams?

In terms of the numbers alone, the answer is yes – and no.

Swapping Neale's statistical output with Beams' this year would have lifted Brisbane equal-fifth to third for average clearances per game, but dropped the Lions to 13th for goals per game, down from 10th.

CLUB LISTS COMPARED Oldest? Youngest? Most experienced?

The Lions are in a rare situation. Most teams that lose a genuine star rely on several players to fill the void, and often struggle to fill the sizeable hole.

Instead, Neale's arrival from Fremantle gives coach Chris Fagan an immediate Beams replacement whose output will be similarly elite, but not identical.

While the former Brisbane captain ranked No.16 in the AFL for average clearances last season, Neale was even better in that regard, coming in at No.5.

If Neale's extra 1.5 clearances per game were added to the Lions' 2018 tally, they would have jumped into to the League's top three, behind only Port Adelaide and Greater Western Sydney.

WHO SMASHED IT? Your club's draft verdict

However, the prodigal Magpie has the former Docker well and truly covered forward of centre. Beams was superior in several areas:

  • Goals (an extra 0.4 per game)
  • Score involvements (an extra one per game)
  • Inside 50s (an extra 0.8 per game)
  • Metres gained (an extra 130m per game)

Again, replace Beams' output in 2018 with Neale's, and the Lions would have dropped from No.10 to No.13 in goals per game, and from No.5 to No.8 for marks inside 50 per game.


It's not a perfect analysis, since other factors such as the different roles they were asked to play aren't considered, but it offers validation for the eye test, which suggests Neale does his best work inside the contest while Beams is a more potent attacking threat.

Over the past two seasons, Beams has picked up at least 25 disposals and two goals on 10 occasions.

To put that into perspective, Neale has managed that combination just six times throughout his 135-game career.

TOUGHEST DRAW? Champion Data ranks every club

However, the recruitment of Jarryd Lyons from Gold Coast and the expected improvement of third-year midfielders Jarrod Berry and Hugh McCluggage should free Neale up to go forward more.

2017's No.1 draft pick, Cam Rayner, will also be keen to fill some of the attacking void left by Beams' departure after booting 20.14 in his debut season.

Both Berry and McCluggage are coming off their second seasons and boosted their clearances by a combined 2.5 per game in 2018.

Further development, along with the 7.3 clearances Lyons averaged this year, would give Fagan more flexibility when deciding how to deploy Neale.

The dual Fremantle best and fairest has shown previously he can thrive in attack, booting four goals against Melbourne in round four, 2017 in one such display, and it's a trait Fagan will likely want to lean on.