ALASTAIR Clarkson has delivered a scathing review of the modern game, blaming the way it is being adjudicated for the "dreadful" spectacle it has become.

HAWKS GET HOME, JUST Full match coverage and stats

In an extraordinary and unrelenting rant lasting more than 10 minutes, the four-time Hawthorn premiership coach restated his belief that more free kicks for incorrect disposal must be paid.

06:33 Mins
Published on

Highlights: Hawthorn v North Melbourne

The Hawks and Kangaroos clash in round four

Published on

Clarkson's comments came on the same day Geelong and Melbourne kicked four goals between them to half-time of their earlier match at the MCG.

He pointed to the Hawks' 69 tackles, as well as beaten foe North Melbourne's 47, and wondered why there were so few holding-the-ball decisions. 

04:42 Mins
Published on

The 10: Round four's best moments

Watch all the best highlights from a thrilling round four

Published on

Clarkson said it was a backroom battle he had fought "for four or five years" with AFL rulemakers but that both they and some other coaches felt the "ball player" needed to be protected. 

BARRETT Could a four-game star upstage two of the greats?

"I hope I'm not the only one who thought it was a dreadful game? There's just no highlights in the game. We got a result, we bank it and move on," Clarkson said post-game. 

"I don't think North played well and I don't think Hawthorn played well. 

"We had 69 tackles and I don't think we had a free kick from a tackle – 69 tackles and not one of them can be adjudicated holding the ball?

It's just like, 'What's happened to our game?'

"You wonder why the game is an arm wrestle and you can't get any open footy. Tonight's game, if that's the spectacle we're trying to search for in our game, our game is in a dreadful space.

"But we're better than that and I think we can do a hell of a lot better by opening the game up a little bit and adjudicating some of those holding the balls." 

11:11 Mins
Published on

Clarko: 'It was a dreadful game'

Alastair Clarkson didn't hold back in his assessment of the match and the AFL as a whole, stating 'our game's in a dreadful space'

Published on

The Hawks led by 31 points midway through the last quarter but barely hung on after the Kangaroos rattled home with four goals in a row to fall four points short. 

However, Clarkson had no interest in discussing where his side went wrong at the end, saying North's comeback owed mostly to "free kicks from stoppage". 

NINE THINGS WE LEARNED The toughest Pie to replace

Asked what he did like from Sunday night's game, he replied: "Nothing." 

Star Hawk Tom Mitchell is surrounded by a mob of Kangaroos opponents. Picture: Getty Images/AFL Photos

Clarkson also rejected Cats coach Chris Scott's suggestion that a move to 16 players on the field for each team might be the secret to unlocking more free-flowing matches. 


11:42 Mins
Published on

Scott on Stewart: 'He's broken his collarbone'

Chris Scott reveals star defender Tom Stewart is suspected to have suffered a broken collarbone in his side's narrow win over Melbourne

Published on

"Every coach would sit there and say, 'We want to try and coach more attacking footy and devote a whole summer doing that'," he said. 

"But then we have to make radical suggestions like, 'Let's go to 16-a-side to change it'. How about changing it in the first instance by governing the game, according to the rulebook?" 

North Melbourne coach Rhyce Shaw sidestepped the discussion, preferring to focus on his players' failure to play in anything more than patches against Hawthorn's strong defence.

Captain Jack Ziebell rolled an ankle in the first quarter and left the game for good in the final term because of a left hamstring issue and is in serious doubt for next week.

00:15 Mins
Published on

Huge blow as Roo skipper pings hammy

North Melbourne suffer a late concern as captain Jack Ziebell is forced to leave the field with a suspected hamstring injury

Published on

"He rolled his ankle pretty badly in that first quarter. He soldiered on really well," Shaw said. 

"He's the captain of the side, he put himself into the middle of the ground, got us going at periods there leading into half-time. 

"I don't know how bad the hammy is. It was bad enough to keep him out, so that's not a great sign for Jack."

An injured Jack Ziebell talks with Shaun Higgins after North Melbourne's loss to Hawthorn. Picture: Getty Images/AFL Photos

Ziebell's dual injuries followed reigning Syd Barker medallist Ben Cunnington being a late withdrawal for the second straight week. 

Cunnington is dealing with a nerve impingement in his back. 

FANTASY FORM WATCH Patience runs thin with below-par stars

"It's a pain in the butt, to be honest. It's not ideal for Ben, it's not ideal for us," Shaw said.

"He looked really good at a point during the week, did a little bit of a run around and a kick and it seemed like he was improving but he just woke up and it's just not to the standard. 

"We can't roll him out there and give him the best chance of playing when he can't bend down."