Collingwood players after the Grand Final between Collingwood and Geelong at the MCG, October 1, 2011. Picture: AFL Photos

COLLINGWOOD is in rare air - again - but history should keep the Magpies on their toes.

Just two years after being 14-2 on the way to a premiership, the Magpies are again flying high as flag favourites.

Friday night's thrashing of arch-rival Carlton means the Magpies have won 14 of their first 16 games of the season and lost just once since their Opening Round defeat to Greater Western Sydney.

As others jostle for top-two, top-four and top-eight spots, Craig McRae's side is flying on the back of eight straight wins as it sets its sights on a second flag in three seasons.

But history suggests teams who have enjoyed such strong first halves of a season have had mixed results come the business end.

Geelong players embrace after the final siren of the Grand Final between St Kilda and Geelong at the MCG, September 26, 2009. Picture: AFL Photos

Since 2000, 10 seasons have had a team which has been 14-2 or better, with 2009, 2011 and 2023 featuring two such sides.

In those 10 seasons, five of those teams have gone on to win the premiership. It's a 50 per cent strike rate that will keep the Magpies on their toes.

Excluding the three seasons that had two teams with records of 14-2 or better, only two of seven went on to win the premiership.

Essendon (2000) won the flag after being 16-0, but lost the Grand Final the following year having been 14-2.

James Hird after the 2001 Grand Final between Essendon and Brisbane at the MCG, September 29, 2001. Picture: AFL Photos

West Coast (2005), Adelaide (2006) and Geelong (2008) fell at the final hurdle before the Cats made amends the following year, against St Kilda, which had been 16-0.

Collingwood and Geelong met in 2011 after dominant starts to the campaign, while Hawthorn won the flag two years later after also making a strong start.

But Fremantle fell in a preliminary final in 2015, while Port Adelaide made a straight-sets exit in 2023, the same year the Pies won the flag.

Port Adelaide players after the Semi Final between Port Adelaide and Greater Western Sydney at Adelaide Oval, September 16, 2023. Picture: Getty Images

McRae said not in the Pies' "wildest dreams" did they expect to reach 14 wins so early in the season, and he can now manage the oldest and most experienced list in the competition as required.

The Pies have positioned themselves perfectly for a record-breaking 17th VFL/AFL premiership, but history suggests it's no sure thing.

Teams which have been 14-2 or better since 2000

Year

Team

Record

Final H&A record

Finish

2000

Essendon

16-0

21-1

Premier

2001

Essendon

14-2

17-5

Lost GF

2005

West Coast

15-1

17-5

Lost GF

2006

Adelaide

14-2

16-6

Lost PF

2008

Geelong

15-1

21-1

Lost GF

2009

St Kilda

16-0

20-2

Lost GF

2009

Geelong

14-2

18-4

Premier

2011

Geelong

14-2

19-3

Premier

2011

Collingwood

15-1

20-2

Lost GF

2013

Hawthorn

14-2

19-3

Premier

2015

Fremantle

14-2

17-5

Lost PF

2023

Collingwood

14-2

18-5

Premier

2023

Port Adelaide

14-2

17-6

Lost SF

2025

Collingwood

14-2